Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Opposition to nudity is ideological.

As a European, it is a very American Puritan thing to have.





I particular when every American blockbuster and TV show needs more girls with generous breasts and love scenes than actual plot and actors, but plain clothed girls holding hands online is nudity.

Not sex, violence.

Somewhere along the way we decided that kids can't see boobs until they're 21, but should be fine watching people get murdered.

I don't have the words for it, but it seems like everyone is fine with MASSIVE violence in every piece of media. I feel like I've lost the plot somewhere.


It went off the rails with Game of Thrones. Before that hyperviolence was found mostly in horror movies, and that's fine imo, it's a specific genre. But nowadays it's in so many shows and movies.

All the american action movies we watched in the 80s and 90s with Rambo and Schwarzenegger etc were all about violence? Most American movies seem to work guns into them somehow too.

American TV has always been violent. It may have been less gory in the past, but there has always been gun fights and fist fights and violence of many kinds.

You definitely haven't been paying attention to blockbusters and TV shows over the past decade or so have you?

They have become remarkably sexless, practically no titillation to be found anywhere


Probably depends on how one defines "blockbuster"...

Yes, the highest-grossing movies (Marvel, etc) tend to be mostly sexless (aside from tight-fitting costumes and dirty jokes).

But, there are always plenty of critically acclaimed Hollywood movies with lots of sex. Poor Things being a recent example.


> Probably depends on how one defines "blockbuster"..

Movies that everyone sees that penetrate the public consciousness

> there are always plenty of critically acclaimed Hollywood movies

Movies that only critics see or care about are not blockbusters


I have different netflix recommendations then you, apparently.

I was going to say that. Also other US stuff I see: a lot of pointless sex and nudity.

<cough> Game of Thrones... the hollywood idea of a "mature" series.

Provide examples of when plain-clothed girls holding hands has ever been treated as nudity please.

Especially when you can post actual harmful stuff like group hate and threats - no problem. What an absolutely moronic world we live in.

As if the US is the only culture with these taboos and religious beliefs when it comes to nudity...

It's one of the strictest in the western world though. Together with the UK.

I never said it was the only one. Of course, there's other examples. Strict Islamic cultures come to mind.

However, it isn't universal. It is a specific ideological choice - that's my point!


US culture imperialism. Only the US culture is right. Every other is wrong. This has been going on for 40 years with TV and then on the internet with social media.

[flagged]


No need to be racist.

[flagged]


The content policy is ideology, that's my point.

It's not some neutral statement, it's a codified ideological creed.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: