Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Interestingly, Alan Moore manages to miss the point and be spot-on at the same time.

Nowhere does he seem to cotton to the nature of Anonymous, the disavowal of identity that accompanies taking up the mask: even though _he himself_ demonstrated the succession of V.

But that's perhaps to be expected; the movie necessarily completed the image of the mask by making it abundantly clear that it is when the _group_ takes up the mask that the mask has power. You cannot punish one if you must punish all.

At the same time, he is clearly in tune with the movement. "Today's response to similar oppressions seems to be one that is intelligent, constantly evolving and considerably more humane."

All in all I read (if I may) V for Valediction from a man who thanks the movement for validating his work, and encourages the next generation just as an intellectual parent ought.

And also like a good intellectual parent, he points to his own heritage... "Some ghosts never go away..."



For what it's worth, he hasn't seen the movie. Any differences in message between his comic and the adaptation have either found him strictly via hearsay or are lost on him entirely.


He hasn't seen the movie, but he did read its script:

    I've read the screenplay, so I know exactly what they're doing with it,
    and I'm not going to be going to see it. 
http://www.mtv.com/shared/movies/interviews/m/moore_alan_060...


> Nowhere does he seem to cotton to the nature of Anonymous

By “cotton” did you mean “caught on”?


Colloquial American English expression, used appropriately. "To cotton to" is to understand and possibly enjoy a phenomenon -- it's always a positive connotation.



Don't know why you're being down-voted, I've never heard the term either.



> You cannot punish one if you must punish all.

That's mindless twaddle.

"if you must punish all" is never true. In fact, you usually don't want to punish all.

And, you can always punish one.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: