Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Speed limits are another realm in which regulation can hold back the development of driverless cars, besides merely allowing them on the streets in the first place.

With computerized drivers, it will finally be possible to fully enforce speed limits, by introducing some ceiling to the speed attainable by the car. I'm sure some "well-meaning" legislator will make it his or her priority to ensure that speed limits are never exceeded. However, at least in Massachusetts, if you go on the highway, everyone (including police) drive at ~75 MPH even though the posted speed limit is 55 or 65 MPH. Few will buy a car with this kind of handicap, were it to exist -- and I worry that it will. Many speed limits in the US were imposed decades ago, with less safe and responsive cars -- it would be a pity if potentially revolutionary technology advances were thwarted by this fact.

Legislation has already crippled or made useless many useful automotive innovations. In the US, technologies that allow for adaptive cruise control (maintaining a distance to the car in front of you) can only decelerate the car, and not accelerate the car. This forces the driver to have to constantly accelerate, greatly reducing the effectiveness of this feature. Many computer-laden vehicles with navigation systems are similarly crippled -- they automatically "lock" when the car is in motion, and some (like in Lexus vehicles) cannot even be overridden by people sitting in the passenger seat... often causing unintended risks like drivers pulling over on busy highways just to readjust their GPS target.



Or they introduce a robot-only lane where the cars can decide for themselves what a safe speed it, making speed limits obsolete. When cars can communicate with each other about dangers, much higher speeds are possible with less distance between cars.


An absolutely fantastic idea. It's a shame it will never happen.


If firmware is limiting your car's speed, the firmware will get reverse engineered and patched to allow any speed.

Jailbroken cars: mark my words, that will happen the day after automated drivers are released.


With computerized drivers, it will finally be possible to fully enforce speed limits

Why the hell would you want speed limits on a road with computerized cars? That's the whole point of eliminating human error and human limitations from the control loop, that 200 mph+ driving can be extremely safe.


Speed limits, in some areas, also serve to limit noise.


That is probably a small fraction of all speed limits.


Yes, at the moment. But if safety goes away as an issue, we will hit the issue of sound next.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: