Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What you're proposing isn't a good thing. It's an ugly, environmentally unfriendly, anti-consumer model.

How many people are debt-financing their $800+ iPhone? How much value is that extracting from people, and what are the opportunity costs for them?

What's the environmental impact of phones becoming nothing more than expensive bricks after 2-3 years due to lack of vendor support, coupled platform DRM that prevents re-use?

What happens when market choices disappear along with the very concept of ownership?

This dystopian ideal of inescapable corporatism may be a commercially viable, but it's not remotely ethical.



> phones becoming nothing more than expensive bricks after 2-3 years due to lack of vendor support, coupled platform DRM that prevents re-use?

I have repurposed my old Samsung android phones around the house as displays on the walls. They all have the net connection shut down and I use the wifi. They all work great and I see no reason they won't work until the hardware dies.

I know this is only one data point. Can someone describe how other models of phones can become bricks?

Edit: People less weird than me can still use the phones like tablets are used without a radio connection.


> Can someone describe how other models of phones can become bricks?

iPhone's have a fully DRM'd trust chain, starting with the bootloader, which is itself on-die and immutable.

Installing a new OS image requires online activation with Apple's servers, which return public-key signed installation permission.

Unless there's a vulnerability that allows jailbreak, you're not installing non-Apple-approved software on that device.

That's the future of the fully centralized/cloud-based 'software iteration business model ... making inroads into the hardware market'


Ah, I understand what you are saying now. Technically, not being able to install new software isn't bricked since you can still run the old. I only run the browser on my old phones so I didn't notice this.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: